Introduction
The long-term stability of Earth’s internal temperature presents one of the most fundamental challenges in geophysics. If the mantle behaves adiabatically below approximately 120 km depth, as seismic and experimental evidence suggests, then its temperature should remain nearly constant through time. Under these conditions, the balance between internal heat generation and total surface heat loss must be remarkably precise.
In Earth’s early history, the quantity of radioactive elements such as uranium, thorium, and potassium was significantly higher, producing far greater radiogenic heat than at present. This excess energy would have been released through more vigorous mantle convection, enhanced volcanic and tectonic activity, and greater rates of heat transfer through the lithosphere. The total surface heat flow during that period must therefore have exceeded today’s ~47 terawatts (TW). Although the magnitude of these variations can be estimated from isotopic decay rates and thermal evolution models, the exact contributions of each geological process remain uncertain.
Despite these temporal fluctuations in radiogenic power and heat loss, the average mantle temperature appears to have remained nearly constant throughout Earth’s history. This implies a long-term self-regulating thermal system, in which higher heat production automatically enhances convective and radiative efficiency, maintaining near-adiabatic conditions and preventing significant temperature drift over geological time.
This stability suggests that the Earth’s internal heat budget operates as a closed but dynamic system, governed primarily by the amount and distribution of radiogenic elements and by the efficiency of internal heat transport processes.
Geoneutrino Constraints and Radiogenic Uncertainty
Recent geoneutrino measurements provide valuable insight into radiogenic heat production. These antineutrinos, emitted during the decay of uranium and thorium, allow researchers to estimate total radiogenic power. Current analyses suggest roughly 20 TW of heat is generated radiogenically, but this value carries large uncertainties due to limited detector coverage—most instruments are located on continental crust—and the need to extrapolate mantle contributions from sparse data.
If mantle concentrations of radioactive elements are higher than currently assumed, the true global radiogenic power could approach or even match the 47 TW of measured total surface output. This would reconcile the apparent imbalance between heat production and heat loss. Thus, the prevailing 20 TW estimate should be regarded as a lower bound, pending improved geoneutrino constraints from oceanic and deep-mantle observation sites.
Reconsidering Heat Transport in the Mantle
The conventional model envisions mantle convection as a primarily upward heat-transport system, carrying thermal energy from the interior toward the lithosphere. While this captures the dominant mechanism, it neglects a complementary and critical component: thermal radiation, which can transmit energy in any direction permitted by local gradients, including downward toward the core.
At the extreme pressures and temperatures near the core–mantle boundary, the mantle’s mineral phases cannot retain stable crystalline structures. The intense radiation field continuously destabilizes any emerging crystals, preventing their persistence and leaving the material in a vitreous, radiation-permeable state. Under these conditions, thermal radiation from the overlying mantle can pass almost undisturbed. Consequently, a portion of the mantle’s internal energy, instead of being entirely convected upward, is radiated downward into the core, effectively heating the core from above.
In contrast, convection transfers heat upward through the large-scale motion of mantle material: hotter, less dense regions rise, while cooler, denser regions sink. These convection rolls maintain global circulation and determine the spatial distribution of surface heat flow. Their geometry, wavelength, and coupling between different mantle layers provide the mechanical framework through which this energy is released.
Together, these two complementary processes—radiative transfer downward and convective transport upward—define the mantle’s dual role in Earth’s thermal system. The lower mantle acts as a radiatively transparent medium, facilitating energy exchange between the mantle and core, while the upper mantle remains convectively active, ensuring efficient heat release toward the surface. This dual mechanism explains how the mantle can sustain an adiabatic thermal gradient over geological timescales, maintaining both the activity of the core and the global tectonic system.
Implications for Earth’s Thermal Evolution
If downward-directed radiation continuously supplies heat to the outer core, then the core’s thermal history may be influenced not only by its own decay heat and latent crystallization, but also by a persistent influx from the mantle. This would help maintain the geodynamo over billions of years and explain why the core remains partially molten despite the decline in radiogenic elements.
The result is a self-regulating thermal system: radiative transfer prevents the mantle from cooling too rapidly, while convective circulation stabilizes surface heat loss. The two mechanisms together preserve a long-term thermal equilibrium that is more intricate and stable than models based solely on convection and conduction.
In this framework, Earth’s internal energy balance is dynamically self-sustaining, with the mantle acting simultaneously as the conveyor and the moderator of heat flow. Recognizing the interplay between radiative and convective processes is therefore essential for understanding the persistence of Earth’s internal heat, the endurance of its magnetic field, and the continuing vitality of plate tectonics.
Magic Magma 